• NY Apartment Law
  • Fair & Affordable Housing
  • Commercial Lease Law
  • Guidebooks
  • Archives
  • Main Articles
  • Model Lease Clauses
  • Q&A
  • Dos & Don'ts
  • Recent Court Rulings
  • eAlerts
  • Log In
  • Log Out
  • My Account
  • Subscribe
  • NY Apartment Law
  • New York Apartment Law Insider
  • New York Landlord V. Tenant
  • Co-Op & Condo Case Law Digest
  • New York Rent Regulation Checklist, Fourth Edition
  • 2025 New York City Apartment Management Checklist
  • Fair & Affordable Housing
  • Fair Housing Coach
  • Assisted Housing Management Insider
  • Tax Credit Housing Management Insider
  • Fair Housing Boot Camp. Basic Training For New Hires
  • Commercial Lease Law
  • Commercial Lease Law Insider
  • Best Commercial Lease Clauses, 17/e
  • Best Commercial Lease Clauses: Tenant's Edition
  • Best Commercial Lease Clauses, 17/e
  • Best Commercial Lease Clauses, 17/e
  • Main Articles
  • Features
  • Broker's Buzz
  • Drafting Tips
  • In the News
  • Negotiating Tips
  • Plugging Loopholes
  • Traps to Avoid
  • Model Lease Clauses
  • Model Lease Clauses
  • Model Agreements
  • Other Model Tools
  • Q&A
  • Q&A
  • Pop Quiz
  • Winners & Losers
  • Ask the Insider
  • Recent Court Rulings
  • Landlord Wins
  • Landlord Loses
May 24, 2025
We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies in accordance with our Cookie Policy.
The Habitat Group Logo
  • NY Apartment Law
    • New York Apartment Law Insider
    • New York Landlord V. Tenant
    • Co-Op & Condo Case Law Digest
    • New York Rent Regulation Checklist, Fourth Edition
    • 2025 New York City Apartment Management Checklist
  • Fair & Affordable Housing
    • Fair Housing Coach
    • Assisted Housing Management Insider
    • Tax Credit Housing Management Insider
    • Fair Housing Boot Camp. Basic Training For New Hires
  • Commercial Lease Law
    • Commercial Lease Law Insider
    • Best Commercial Lease Clauses, 17/e
      • Best Commercial Lease Clauses, 17/e
    • Best Commercial Lease Clauses: Tenant's Edition
  • Guidebooks
  • May 24, 2025
  • Log In
  • Log Out
  • My Account
  • Subscribe
  • May 24, 2025
CLLI_logo_2020.jpg
  • Archives
  • Main Articles
    • Features
    • Broker's Buzz
    • Drafting Tips
    • In the News
    • Negotiating Tips
    • Plugging Loopholes
    • Traps to Avoid
  • Model Lease Clauses
    • Model Lease Clauses
    • Model Agreements
    • Other Model Tools
  • Q&A
    • Q&A
    • Pop Quiz
    • Winners & Losers
    • Ask the Insider
  • Dos & Don'ts
  • Recent Court Rulings
    • Landlord Wins
    • Landlord Loses
  • eAlerts
Free Issue
The Habitat Group Logo
May 24, 2025
  • Log In
  • Log Out
  • My Account
Home » Constructive Eviction Claim Not Valid

Constructive Eviction Claim Not Valid

Feb 25, 2013

Facts: A tenant who provided physical therapy services rented space on the top floor of a five-story building. After three months, the tenant stopped paying full rent. The owner sued the tenant to recover the space and won. The tenant sued the owner for constructive eviction. The tenant claimed that the owner’s failure to maintain the site and elevator caused it to lose many patients, and to suffer numerous cancellations, leading to it losing $250,000 in business.

Decision: A New York trial court ruled in favor of the owner.

Reasoning: To prove that it was constructively evicted, the tenant had to show that the acts of the owner “precluded her from the use and enjoyment of the premises.” Here, the tenant alleged that: (1) the leased space was rendered unusable by the lack of elevator service and other maintenance problems in the building; (2) the owner failed to make elevator repairs in a timely manner; and (3) the tenant’s business was partially evicted and constructively evicted from the premises by the lack of essential services. For example, many of the tenant’s clients included the elderly, recently injured, and those who had recently undergone surgery; the use of the elevator was required for the tenant’s business since it was impossible for a patient with a knee injury, hip replacement, or in a wheelchair to reach the third floor without an operable elevator.

In a claim dealing with the issue of rent, it’s not sufficient for the tenant to defend its nonpayment of rent on the theory that there was a diminution of the beneficial enjoyment of the property, argued the owner. The owner asserted that the obligation to pay rent is not suspended even if a landlord fails to provide essential services. And, according to the owner, the tenant must actually physically abandon the premises in order to claim a constructive eviction.

“To invoke a constructive eviction defense, there must be a substantial interference with the tenant’s use and enjoyment of the leased premises, including access to goods and services, which causes the tenant to vacate the premises,” said the court. In this case, the tenant wasn’t removed from the premises, noted the court. In fact, the tenant remained in possession of the space through 27 months, and only left because the owner sought, and won, possession of the premises in a holdover proceeding. Additionally, the tenant wasn’t relieved of her fundamental obligation to pay rent even if the owner failed to provide essential services, the court added.

  • Winner Communications, Inc. v. Bell, February 2013
Owner Wins
      • Related Articles

        Tenant Can't Claim Constructive Eviction

        Tenant Can't Claim Constructive Eviction While Occupying Space

        Disruption of Power Supply Not Enough to Prove Constructive Eviction

      • Publications
        • Assisted Housing Management Insider
        • Commercial Lease Law Insider
        • Co-op & Condo Case Law Tracker Digest
        • Fair Housing Coach
        • New York Apartment Law Insider
        • New York Landlord v. Tenant
        • Tax Credit Housing Management Insider
      • Additional Links
        • Contact Us
        • Advertise
        • Group Subscriptions
        • Privacy Policy
      • Boards of Advisors
        • Assisted Housing Management Insider
        • Commercial Lease Law Insider
        • Fair Housing Coach
        • New York Apartment Law Insider
        • Tax Credit Housing Management Insider
      ©2025. All Rights Reserved. Content: The Habitat Group. CMS, Hosting & Web Development: ePublishing
      The Habitat Group Logo
      • NY Apartment Law
        • New York Apartment Law Insider
        • New York Landlord V. Tenant
        • Co-Op & Condo Case Law Digest
        • New York Rent Regulation Checklist, Fourth Edition
        • 2025 New York City Apartment Management Checklist
      • Fair & Affordable Housing
        • Fair Housing Coach
        • Assisted Housing Management Insider
        • Tax Credit Housing Management Insider
        • Fair Housing Boot Camp. Basic Training For New Hires
      • Commercial Lease Law
        • Commercial Lease Law Insider
        • Best Commercial Lease Clauses, 17/e
          • Best Commercial Lease Clauses, 17/e
        • Best Commercial Lease Clauses: Tenant's Edition
      • Guidebooks
      • May 24, 2025
      • Log In
      • Log Out
      • My Account
      • Subscribe
      • May 24, 2025
      CLLI_logo_2020.jpg
      • Archives
      • Main Articles
        • Features
        • Broker's Buzz
        • Drafting Tips
        • In the News
        • Negotiating Tips
        • Plugging Loopholes
        • Traps to Avoid
      • Model Lease Clauses
        • Model Lease Clauses
        • Model Agreements
        • Other Model Tools
      • Q&A
        • Q&A
        • Pop Quiz
        • Winners & Losers
        • Ask the Insider
      • Dos & Don'ts
      • Recent Court Rulings
        • Landlord Wins
        • Landlord Loses
      • eAlerts
      Free Issue
      The Habitat Group Logo
      May 24, 2025
      • Log In
      • Log Out
      • My Account