• NY Apartment Law
  • Fair & Affordable Housing
  • Commercial Lease Law
  • Guidebooks
  • Archives
  • Main Articles
  • Model Lease Clauses
  • Q&A
  • Dos & Don'ts
  • Recent Court Rulings
  • eAlerts
  • Log In
  • Log Out
  • My Account
  • Subscribe
  • NY Apartment Law
  • New York Apartment Law Insider
  • New York Landlord V. Tenant
  • Co-Op & Condo Case Law Digest
  • New York Rent Regulation Checklist, Fourth Edition
  • 2025 New York City Apartment Management Checklist
  • Fair & Affordable Housing
  • Fair Housing Coach
  • Assisted Housing Management Insider
  • Tax Credit Housing Management Insider
  • Fair Housing Boot Camp. Basic Training For New Hires
  • Commercial Lease Law
  • Commercial Lease Law Insider
  • Best Commercial Lease Clauses, 17/e
  • Best Commercial Lease Clauses: Tenant's Edition
  • Best Commercial Lease Clauses, 17/e
  • Best Commercial Lease Clauses, 17/e
  • Main Articles
  • Features
  • Broker's Buzz
  • Drafting Tips
  • In the News
  • Negotiating Tips
  • Plugging Loopholes
  • Traps to Avoid
  • Model Lease Clauses
  • Model Lease Clauses
  • Model Agreements
  • Other Model Tools
  • Q&A
  • Q&A
  • Pop Quiz
  • Winners & Losers
  • Ask the Insider
  • Recent Court Rulings
  • Landlord Wins
  • Landlord Loses
July 16, 2025
We use cookies to provide you with a better experience. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies in accordance with our Cookie Policy.
The Habitat Group Logo
  • NY Apartment Law
    • New York Apartment Law Insider
    • New York Landlord V. Tenant
    • Co-Op & Condo Case Law Digest
    • New York Rent Regulation Checklist, Fourth Edition
    • 2025 New York City Apartment Management Checklist
  • Fair & Affordable Housing
    • Fair Housing Coach
    • Assisted Housing Management Insider
    • Tax Credit Housing Management Insider
    • Fair Housing Boot Camp. Basic Training For New Hires
  • Commercial Lease Law
    • Commercial Lease Law Insider
    • Best Commercial Lease Clauses, 17/e
      • Best Commercial Lease Clauses, 17/e
    • Best Commercial Lease Clauses: Tenant's Edition
  • Guidebooks
  • July 16, 2025
  • Log In
  • Log Out
  • My Account
  • Subscribe
  • July 16, 2025
CLLI_logo_2020.jpg
  • Archives
  • Main Articles
    • Features
    • Broker's Buzz
    • Drafting Tips
    • In the News
    • Negotiating Tips
    • Plugging Loopholes
    • Traps to Avoid
  • Model Lease Clauses
    • Model Lease Clauses
    • Model Agreements
    • Other Model Tools
  • Q&A
    • Q&A
    • Pop Quiz
    • Winners & Losers
    • Ask the Insider
  • Dos & Don'ts
  • Recent Court Rulings
    • Landlord Wins
    • Landlord Loses
  • eAlerts
Free Issue
The Habitat Group Logo
July 16, 2025
  • Log In
  • Log Out
  • My Account
Home » Competing Tenant Not Liable Under Exclusive Right

Competing Tenant Not Liable Under Exclusive Right

Sep 28, 2009

Facts: A real estate company and an insurance company that were joint owners of a shopping center signed a declaration creating restrictive covenants that were to run with the land on which the center was built. Under the declaration, a tenant that sold food and drugs had an exclusive right to operate a “grocery store” in the shopping center. The grocery store leased its space from the real estate company, which had purchased its share of the shopping center mainly because of this exclusive right for its tenant. The declaration stated that “the developer covenants and agrees that it shall not permit the use or operation of any building in the shopping center, or any space therein, other than the Store building, for the sale of groceries, package liquor, beer or wine, or for similar food purposes larger than 2,000 square feet in size.” The term “developer” was not defined.

An anchor tenant that leased shopping center space from the insurance company sold various merchandise, including snacks and other food items. The real estate company and the grocery store alleged that the anchor tenant was selling grocery items in violation of the grocery store's exclusive right, and sued it and the insurance company.

The anchor tenant asked the court for judgment in its favor without a trial. It argued that, as a tenant, it could not be liable under the exclusive right provision of the declaration, because the provision imposed a duty to not compete exclusively on the insurance company.

Decision: The court granted a judgment without a trial in the anchor tenant's favor.

Reasoning: The court pointed out that the clear intent of the exclusive right in the declaration was to prevent stores in the shopping center, other than the grocery store, from selling groceries. The issue, however, was who was liable for competition under the declaration: the anchor tenant, the insurance company, or both.

The language in the declaration stated that the “developer” covenants and agrees to the exclusive right, among other things. But that term was unambiguous as to whether the anchor tenant was considered to be a developer along with, or instead of, the insurance company. The court ruled that the responsibility to comply with the declaration fell to the insurance company alone. The anchor tenant was just the competing store it had impermissibly leased space to.

  • Dillon Real Estate Co., Inc., et al. v. American National Insurance Co. and Dollar Tree Stores, Inc., July 2009
Owner Loses
    • Related Articles

      Tenant Not Liable for Accident in Parking Lot Under Landlord’s Control

      Shopping Center Tenant Not Liable for Pre-Assignment Environmental Contamination

      Tenant Granted Use of Extra Space Not Liable for Extra Rent

    • Publications
      • Assisted Housing Management Insider
      • Commercial Lease Law Insider
      • Co-op & Condo Case Law Tracker Digest
      • Fair Housing Coach
      • New York Apartment Law Insider
      • New York Landlord v. Tenant
      • Tax Credit Housing Management Insider
    • Additional Links
      • Contact Us
      • Advertise
      • Group Subscriptions
      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms of Use
    • Boards of Advisors
      • Assisted Housing Management Insider
      • Commercial Lease Law Insider
      • Fair Housing Coach
      • New York Apartment Law Insider
      • Tax Credit Housing Management Insider
    ©2025. All Rights Reserved. Content: The Habitat Group. CMS, Hosting & Web Development: ePublishing
    The Habitat Group Logo
    • NY Apartment Law
      • New York Apartment Law Insider
      • New York Landlord V. Tenant
      • Co-Op & Condo Case Law Digest
      • New York Rent Regulation Checklist, Fourth Edition
      • 2025 New York City Apartment Management Checklist
    • Fair & Affordable Housing
      • Fair Housing Coach
      • Assisted Housing Management Insider
      • Tax Credit Housing Management Insider
      • Fair Housing Boot Camp. Basic Training For New Hires
    • Commercial Lease Law
      • Commercial Lease Law Insider
      • Best Commercial Lease Clauses, 17/e
        • Best Commercial Lease Clauses, 17/e
      • Best Commercial Lease Clauses: Tenant's Edition
    • Guidebooks
    • July 16, 2025
    • Log In
    • Log Out
    • My Account
    • Subscribe
    • July 16, 2025
    CLLI_logo_2020.jpg
    • Archives
    • Main Articles
      • Features
      • Broker's Buzz
      • Drafting Tips
      • In the News
      • Negotiating Tips
      • Plugging Loopholes
      • Traps to Avoid
    • Model Lease Clauses
      • Model Lease Clauses
      • Model Agreements
      • Other Model Tools
    • Q&A
      • Q&A
      • Pop Quiz
      • Winners & Losers
      • Ask the Insider
    • Dos & Don'ts
    • Recent Court Rulings
      • Landlord Wins
      • Landlord Loses
    • eAlerts
    Free Issue
    The Habitat Group Logo
    July 16, 2025
    • Log In
    • Log Out
    • My Account